These needed more arch support for me, but they were cute. Unfortunately I needed this exact style (to replace a very old, but loved pair) and the do-dads on the back don't make it so that these boots could be dressed up or dressed down. Looked cute with a pair of jeans, but I wanted something more versatile. Sadly, they went back.
Oh my, they were uncomfortable and I hardly see boots this style uncomfortable! The leather was stiff and the top end kept digging into my ankle even after trying them. They are just too stiff and without much support.