Though comfortable enough, I'm returning because I didn't think the leather was particularly nice given the price point. It's a soft matte leather but didn't look like it would keep a "sleek" look after some wear. The style is also nearly identical to a Frye Melissa button boot (although leathr is different and Belle toe is slightly narrower).
The leather is soft and the style is nice. I love the grey color. I usually wear an 8.5 or 9 and the 9 is very tight. I have narrow feet and thin calves and I could hardly zip the back of the boot, right by the heel. I am ordering a larger size.