Frye Women's Otis Penny

Priced: $107.99 - $139.99 Rated:   - 5 stars out of 5 by 5 reviews.
Frye Otis Penny
Zoom In
Color: Black
Available Colors:
Visit our Daily Deals for great products at low prices.
Frye Otis Penny - The casually sophisticated style of the Otis Mid Penny by Frye® will easily blend into your everyday look.
Soft vintage leather upper.
Smooth leather lining for a more comfortable fit.
Lightly cushioned leather footbed.
Durable leather outsole.

Lining and Layers:

  • Soft leather lining and lightly cushioned footbed.


  • Rich leather uppers with hand-worked topstitching details on the toe.


  • Subtle Frye branding detail at rear quarter.
As American as apple pie, the ubiquitous penny loafer has been around since the 1930s but still melds perfectly into a captivating look for the modern woman.
Want it cheaper? Set your own price.
Enter the price you want to pay and we'll email or text you if we find a store that will sell it for that amount:
Price: $
Your email:
Cell number: (optional, for text message)
Learn how offers work...
11 people have already set their own price.
Average Price History: Price History
Review RatingNumber of Reviews
Also available for: Men
Heel Height:1 3⁄4 in
Weight:10 oz

Related Categories:


Frye Otis Penny Reviews:


This is really a beautiful shoe. I love the simple but stylish design, and the construction is so solid... pretty much the qualities I most value in a shoe! It definitely runs a bit big (in my view). I normally wear a 9.5 but even the 9.0 is a little roomy for me. However, the 8.5 (which I also tried - thank you Zappos for being so saintly about returns!) was just too tight across that beginning part of the toes (like, where bunions would be if you had them). My feet are average to narrow in width, but my third and 4th toes are nearly as long as my big toe and second toe (so sometimes I have to size up just so that 4th toe isn't squashed).
Karen C - customer at on 12/01/2013
I've never been a big fan of loafers but I've just got some outfits that really seem to need them. And I'm very happy with these: a little bit more of a heel, very soft and comfortable leather. The softness of the leather is actually the reason I gave this 4 instead of 5 stars. I think this shoe really needs a shoe horn so the back doesn't get too broken down. Otherwise, a lovely pair.
Anonymous - customer at on 11/24/2013
These are gorgeous, soft, comfortable and stylish, but I found them to run slightly large. I normally wear a 9 in Frye shoes (often 9.5 in other brands and usually 40 in EU sizes), ordered these in a 9 but they were slightly large. I will try the 8.5 when it is available; since the leather is very soft I expect that even if they are bit snug, they would break in.
Anonymous - customer at on 10/01/2013
Having serious walking issues, all I wanted to know when I got these shoes was: Where have you been all my life?! They are beautiful, the inside is cushioned and soft, the heel height is perfect, shoes don't pinch and they can be worn all day right out of the box. Planning to get a pair in black.
Anonymous - customer at on 10/21/2013
These are lovely shoes! Well-made, very attractive, and extremely comfortable. Cushy and supportive. They fit true to size (I wear 8 medium-width, and they are comfortable out of the box). These are well worth the investment.
Ginger G - customer at on 09/17/2013