Frye Shirley Over-The-Knee Riding

I am a total high heel girl, even when it comes to boots. I wanted an over the knee pair for Fall this year, and I just do not think the over the knee plus high heel works for me. It is a little too "Pretty Woman" for my taste. While waiting for the torturous 48 hours to receive my purchase, (thanks to the Fourth of July holiday!) I decided I just cannot rock a pair of flat boots and when they arrived I would send them back. Wrong. When I opened the box (just to look before I returned them) I was greeted with these gorgeous, buttery leather boots. Of course I had to try them on (just to remind myself that I do not do flat). Due to their soft and pliable leather they fit like a glove. I have very high arches and have experienced heartbreak over having to send back so many beautiful boots because I could not pull them on over my arches. This especially happens to me with the equestrian style of boots, but not with these. The fit is amazing. I think the zipper on the inside of the boot coupled with the softness of the leather is what allowed me to get them on with ease. I am a size 7 and these are true to size for me. Needless to say they have found a home and are not getting returned. In fact I am typing this review while still wearing them because I cannot bear to take them off. They are perfect for fall with skinny jeans or leggings I cannot wait for Fall to arrive! The length of these boots prevents them from looking clunky due to the low heel. They looked classic and sophisticated and were exactly what I was searching for. If you are on the fence about these go ahead and try them. Thanks to Zappos' Legendary customer service and return policy, you have absolutely nothing to lose. I have been hearing about Frye's workmanship and quality for years now and I have to say they live up to their stellar reputation.

These are my first pair of Frye Boots. I'm 5'2" with skinny calves (13 inches). These boots hit 1 to 2 inches above my kneecap (unfolded). They hug my calves just right, not too loose with skinny jeans, so I don't look like I'm playing dress up. The leather feels and smells exquisite - now I know why Frye is so expensive!!! I was hesitant about ordering which size, since reviews say "order half size down or up" so I just ordered my usual 7. I have narrow feet, and I still have about one inch allowance for my toes to move. With these boots, my heels don't lift inside the boots, which is good, because I had that problem when I tried on the Frye Dorado in the store. So far, the ankles haven't dropped or become slouchy. The only thing I don't like about these boots is the sole. I had to put on those traction stickers, so I don't slip and fall on slippery surfaces. Overall, I'm in love with these boots!

Be careful when you buy these boots because when you do...you will want 10 more pairs of Frye boots. These are amazing. I got the black and ordered my normal size (8). They fit amazing! They look so great with skinny jeans and leggings. The leather is so supple and I can tell it will only get better with time. These will last forever! Big investment but if you are looking for great black riding boots, you will not be sorry.

These boots are gorgeous! I'm 5'10" and the size 10 boot was plenty long. It fits perfectly over my knee and looks great up or folded down. The boot scuffs easily, but is equally easy to polish back to perfection. I'm very happy with my investment! I like the close fit around my ankle. Very sexy. Received tons of compliments during my first outing in these boots.

As all the reviews note, this is a beautiful boot. I am very sad to be returning it, because I know I won't find anything of better quality. I planned to wear it with short skirts and mini dresses, and it's just not right for that look--the over-the-knee style makes the leg look like a tree trunk. With jeans or leggings these would be fantastic.