I got these for my 20 month old daughter and even though she is picky, she loves wearing them. They must be very comfortable b/c she doesn't mind putting them on. I understand what other reviewers have said about them being a little stiff but I think that just makes them more durable and it doesn't bother my daughter or rub her foot the wrong way. I think they are well made and will hopefully last longer than some of our other recent shoe purchases. We get a lot of compliments on them.
I can see how these could be uncomfortable if your kid's foot doesn't fit them right, but for our daughter she loves them and they are SUPER durable. Very wide too - so it fits nicely and goes off and on easily. The big rubber toebox is nice if your little one drags their feet... lots of rubber to go through before a hole shows up.
Cute shoes - very durable and well constructed. A little stiff for little feet.
My 2 year old often refuses to wear them. He says ouchie when I put them on and they are not too small. Very stiff but still very cute. I wish he liked them more because I do! :)