GearBuyer
Product Videos Product Reviews Buying Guides

Men's Dress Shoe Reviews

The following men's dress shoe reviews are aggregated from our many retailers to show the best products first.

ProductRatingPrice
Ecco Austin Cap Toe Shoes - Oxford Ecco Austin Cap Toe Shoes - Oxford
  • Outstanding Value Comfortable Dress Shoe
  • Top value shoe suggested by podiatrist
  • Typical Sierra Trading Post quality
****
4.3 based on 39 reviews
$89.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Warren Shoes - Leather Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Warren Shoes - Leather
  • You gotta be kiddin' me! I LOVE 'EM!
  • headline accurately portrays the shoes.
  • I've been looking for these at any price
****
4.6 based on 18 reviews
$164.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Conway Loafers Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Conway Loafers
  • Comfortable and Practice -- What a Combo
  • I've never had an uncomfortable A-E shoe
  • Tour Europe in these shoes!
****
4.5 based on 16 reviews
$116.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Weekender Leather Shoes Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds Weekender Leather Shoes
  • As always, a superbly comfortable shoe
  • More Comfortable Than Any Other Shoes
  • I would purchase a Allen Edmunds product
****
4.5 based on 22 reviews
$110.46
where to buy
Sandro Moscoloni La Vida Tassel Loafers Sandro Moscoloni La Vida Tassel Loafers
  • With a tweak they are perfect
  • Brown Loafers meet the bill.
  • Trust STP's recommendations.
****
4.4 based on 19 reviews
$84.96
where to buy
Josef Seibel Victor Shoes - Loafers Josef Seibel Victor Shoes - Loafers
  • Perhaps the perfect travel shoe
  • Lightweight , comfortable and stylish
  • Great shoes at a fantastic price.
****
4.7 based on 13 reviews
$59.46
where to buy
Sandro Moscoloni Seth Oxford Shoes Sandro Moscoloni Seth Oxford Shoes
  • Not as comfortable as I would have liked
  • Save some bucks on these bucks
  • Great pair of shoes an excellent price
****
4.3 based on 23 reviews
$38.68
where to buy
Johnston & Murphy Norden Shoes - Leather Lace-Ups Johnston & Murphy Norden Shoes - Leather Lace-Ups
  • Extremely comfortable.
  • Nice looking shoe
  • Excellent shoe.
*****
4.8 based on 8 reviews
$67.11
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds McClain Wingtip Shoes - Suede Oxfords Allen Edmonds Allen-Edmonds McClain Wingtip Shoes - Suede Oxfords
  • Classic Elegance, Edmonds Does It Again!
  • Buy Allen-Edmonds Shoes, period.
  • Great pair of shoes outstanding service
*****
4.8 based on 9 reviews
$129.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Monk Strap Leather Loafers Allen Edmonds Monk Strap Leather Loafers
  • Very nice shoe at an excellent price
  • Nice addition to my business shoes
  • Misleading color, poor buckle quality
****
4.0 based on 20 reviews
$188.95
where to buy
Sandro Moscoloni Gardner Shoes - Oxfords Sandro Moscoloni Gardner Shoes - Oxfords
  • a little wide but otherwise good
  • Dressy Casual and Comfortable
  • Wonderful style and fit
****
4.3 based on 14 reviews
$54.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Dover Penny Loafers Allen Edmonds Dover Penny Loafers
  • WOW...No wonder my husband wanted these.
  • Allen-Edmond's Dover Penny Loafers
  • I would buy this product without hesitat
****
4.2 based on 26 reviews
$139.95
where to buy
Allen Edmonds Parkland Penny Loafers - Leather Allen Edmonds Parkland Penny Loafers - Leather
  • Great shoe, be aware of size variance
  • Allen Edmonds - a Superior Shoe
  • Allen Edmonds are the finest shoe made
****
4.6 based on 9 reviews
$169.95
where to buy
Johnston & Murphy Emery Moc-Toe Dress Shoes - Italian Leather Johnston & Murphy Emery Moc-Toe Dress Shoes - Italian Leather
  • Beautiful Shoes -- Small Scratch on Top
  • I really like this product
  • Great SHOE!! Great PRICE!!
****
4.6 based on 5 reviews
$84.96
where to buy
Johnston & Murphy Emery Shoes - Italian Calfkin Johnston & Murphy Emery Shoes - Italian Calfkin
  • Johnston & Murphy Continue to Impress
  • Fabulous shoe, especially for the money.
  • "Really what is there to say?"
*****
4.8 based on 9 reviews
$99.95
where to buy
Josef Seibel Montreal Loafers Josef Seibel Montreal Loafers
  • Looks awesome, fits ok, comfort is so-so
  • Nice shoes, but they're sized too big
  • Does not live up to its usaul standard
****
4.1 based on 13 reviews
$65.95
where to buy
H.S. Trask Bison Gallatin ES Shoes - Slip-Ons H.S. Trask Bison Gallatin ES Shoes - Slip-Ons
  • Quality construction, disappointing fit
  • As comfortable as your running shoes
  • Good Looking but need breaking in
****
3.8 based on 28 reviews
$84.96
where to buy
Michael Toschi Angelo Loafers Michael Toschi Angelo Loafers
  • My 5th pair of Michael Toschi shoes...
  • As anticipated
  • Nice shoe
*****
4.8 based on 4 reviews
$279.95
where to buy
Touch Footwear Taber Shoes - Leather Slip-Ons Touch Footwear Taber Shoes - Leather Slip-Ons
  • Nice shoes, a little heavy/clunky
  • A very nice shoe for the money.
  • Nice Shoe and a good value.
****
4.2 based on 12 reviews
$69.95
where to buy
Tricker's Handmade Wingtip Derby Shoes - Brogue Welted Tricker's Handmade Wingtip Derby Shoes - Brogue Welted
  • Nice, but STP mistakenly sizes them
  • Great Shoe, But Be Careful!
  • Excellent shoe, I would purchase again.
****
4.0 based on 8 reviews
$288.96
where to buy
Born Montgomery Loafers Born Montgomery Loafers
  • Excellent Casual Dress Shoe
  • Nice comfy dressy/casual shoes
  • Great looking and comfortable too!
****
4.0 based on 11 reviews
$77.14
where to buy
Magnanni Felipe Loafers Magnanni Felipe Loafers
  • Nice looking shoes but way too narrow
  • good look worth [$] but tooo small
  • looks great, feels good
****
4.2 based on 10 reviews
$64.95
where to buy
Johnston & Murphy Kennard Shoes - Leather Lace-Ups Johnston & Murphy Kennard Shoes - Leather Lace-Ups
  • Nice shoe, but width is a little tight
  • Great value and well made
  • The best in quality and comfort.
****
4.3 based on 6 reviews
$67.96
where to buy
Johnston & Murphy Parmer Dress Shoes - Leather Oxfords Johnston & Murphy Parmer Dress Shoes - Leather Oxfords
  • Nice product...great value
  • Met Expectations
  • Very nice shoes.
****
4.0 based on 7 reviews
$109.95
where to buy
Touch Footwear Altos Shoes Touch Footwear Altos Shoes
  • Good value, but comfort could be better
  • Stylish shoes for business casuals
  • wonderful product would buy again.
****
3.8 based on 8 reviews
$69.95
where to buy